Same album, different pressing, wildly different price. The first pressing, the label variant, and the sleeve condition drive vinyl value.
How to identify a record
Catalog number — on the label and spine; identifies the pressing.
Label design — label variants mark different pressings/years.
Matrix runout etchings — in the dead wax; the true pressing identifier.
Country of pressing — UK/US first pressings often most valuable.
Sleeve & insert condition — original inner sleeves and inserts add value.
What collectors pay for
First pressings of landmark albums.
Rare/withdrawn pressings (e.g. early covers later changed).
Pristine condition — scratches and warp kill value.
Original inserts and posters.
Pricing
Filter eBay to Sold Items by catalog number, not just album title.
Grade condition honestly (Goldmine standard).
Compare same pressing + condition only.
Scan the label to price it
Thrift Scout reads the catalog number and label, searches to confirm the pressing, and returns sold comps — so a $1 crate find that's a sought-after first pressing doesn't slip away.